Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 5 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
It appears this is not the last novel of the series as new events are far from complete. This Princess Beatrice seems both simple and complicated at the same time, easily coming to the strangest conclusions that are far from the truth and choosing very questionable actions in her desperation to meet her family's demands. Even more than the crown prince, it seems this "Lord Prophet" may be who they should be the most concerned about, and what he has in store for Keith, rather than anything else. It also remains to be seen if Beatrice interacting with Claire's memories could indeed change the events of their past, though hopefully this will be resolved before they reach their current lifetime. Despite this looming threat and the exams they can't risk failing, the entire group seems oddly laid back and excited to be able to get a glimpse of what took place in Claire's first life with them all - especially Vik. I haven't been able to find any information regarding the release of the next installment in the series, so hopefully it won't be too long of a wait for continuity.
View all my reviews
Showing posts with label author: ichibu saki. Show all posts
Showing posts with label author: ichibu saki. Show all posts
February 8, 2026
February 7, 2026
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 4 (Novel)
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 4 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
It is interesting how Prince Gilbert's situation is similar and yet different from Claire's, especially as it seems his story repeated separately from Claire's own experience up until their storylines actually converged. This is also the first time that we actually see any true understanding of the game world from Charlotte despite her frequent ravings that she's the "main character". Events with Prince Gilbert were more than a little concerning, though make some sense from the game's point of view. His actions clearly clashed with the current reality and expectations, though fortunately with Claire's own experience, Vik and his retinue are far more equipped to understand and act on Gilbert's story than others who might be more likely to dismiss his ramblings. It is fortunate that things work out as they do. While the story does have a definite end at this point, there are also some lingering possibilities that might be explored, which would make sense as there is currently at least one more volume after this one in the novel series. Hopefully we'll see more of Claire's happy future come to a reality and far less concerns or troubles than the previous versions of the story have entailed.
View all my reviews
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
It is interesting how Prince Gilbert's situation is similar and yet different from Claire's, especially as it seems his story repeated separately from Claire's own experience up until their storylines actually converged. This is also the first time that we actually see any true understanding of the game world from Charlotte despite her frequent ravings that she's the "main character". Events with Prince Gilbert were more than a little concerning, though make some sense from the game's point of view. His actions clearly clashed with the current reality and expectations, though fortunately with Claire's own experience, Vik and his retinue are far more equipped to understand and act on Gilbert's story than others who might be more likely to dismiss his ramblings. It is fortunate that things work out as they do. While the story does have a definite end at this point, there are also some lingering possibilities that might be explored, which would make sense as there is currently at least one more volume after this one in the novel series. Hopefully we'll see more of Claire's happy future come to a reality and far less concerns or troubles than the previous versions of the story have entailed.
View all my reviews
February 6, 2026
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 3 (Novel)
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 3 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Just when it looks like the story may be wrapping up, we have new lessons to prepare for and a new romance character making an appearance. There is a slight warning of this when Claire returns to the modern world once again, but it seems more similar to her first dream visit rather than like the times when her power drained, making it even more confusing. This new character seems to have some knowledge potentially of events given his acceptance of Charlotte as the "main character" and his unusual interest in Claire. Hopefully this won't be too problematic, especially after the bombshells at the last ball take place. At least Nicola seems to be a much better match with current relations being what they are, as well as the building friendship between Noston and Paffuto. We learn a bit more about Claire's grandmother as well, though her visions and interference in the story still seem to be unknown a lot of the time and leaves questions remaining as to what she actually saw. Ideally, there won't be as much of a wait for Claire and Vik, especially now that it seems the entire royal family is onboard with Vik's plans.
View all my reviews
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Just when it looks like the story may be wrapping up, we have new lessons to prepare for and a new romance character making an appearance. There is a slight warning of this when Claire returns to the modern world once again, but it seems more similar to her first dream visit rather than like the times when her power drained, making it even more confusing. This new character seems to have some knowledge potentially of events given his acceptance of Charlotte as the "main character" and his unusual interest in Claire. Hopefully this won't be too problematic, especially after the bombshells at the last ball take place. At least Nicola seems to be a much better match with current relations being what they are, as well as the building friendship between Noston and Paffuto. We learn a bit more about Claire's grandmother as well, though her visions and interference in the story still seem to be unknown a lot of the time and leaves questions remaining as to what she actually saw. Ideally, there won't be as much of a wait for Claire and Vik, especially now that it seems the entire royal family is onboard with Vik's plans.
View all my reviews
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 2 (Novel)
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 2 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
As hoped, this takes us just past current events in the manga. We also get a lot more insight on Vik's side of events, and even Dion shares the spotlight a bit, which adds more dimension to the rest of the story. Prince Asbert makes an appearance as well following the meeting with Aunt Anne, which leaves about as many questions as answers regarding the situation with Charlotte. It looks like Aunt Anne is preemptively making a move herself with the drinks at the ball, though it's yet to be seen how things will play out now that Charlotte's powers have awakened. It will be curious as well to see if everyone remains as clear from her influence as they currently are, and what it will mean with Nicola transfering to the Noston academy. At least it appears that everyone with any idea of how things are playing out in Paffuto seem supportive of Claire and Vik, though it's somewhat muted by the forced delays. Claire does have a point, as always, though hopefully it won't add any additional strains now that things are slowly working out. It will be curious to see if they must wait until the tornado and/or the next ball following as in the past or if another opportunity will arise. It seems Vik and Keith are keeping him apprised of things, so it is unlikely to be a surprise at least. If he is as amenable and supportive as he was the first time around, there should not be any difficulties. Can't help but feel something will happen with Charlotte, but hopefully it will not result in as much of a tragedy this time around with all of these new ties and plans in motion.
View all my reviews
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
As hoped, this takes us just past current events in the manga. We also get a lot more insight on Vik's side of events, and even Dion shares the spotlight a bit, which adds more dimension to the rest of the story. Prince Asbert makes an appearance as well following the meeting with Aunt Anne, which leaves about as many questions as answers regarding the situation with Charlotte. It looks like Aunt Anne is preemptively making a move herself with the drinks at the ball, though it's yet to be seen how things will play out now that Charlotte's powers have awakened. It will be curious as well to see if everyone remains as clear from her influence as they currently are, and what it will mean with Nicola transfering to the Noston academy. At least it appears that everyone with any idea of how things are playing out in Paffuto seem supportive of Claire and Vik, though it's somewhat muted by the forced delays. Claire does have a point, as always, though hopefully it won't add any additional strains now that things are slowly working out. It will be curious to see if they must wait until the tornado and/or the next ball following as in the past or if another opportunity will arise. It seems Vik and Keith are keeping him apprised of things, so it is unlikely to be a surprise at least. If he is as amenable and supportive as he was the first time around, there should not be any difficulties. Can't help but feel something will happen with Charlotte, but hopefully it will not result in as much of a tragedy this time around with all of these new ties and plans in motion.
View all my reviews
February 5, 2026
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 1 (Novel)
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 1 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
This covers a few of the volumes in the manga, as expected. While there are some descriptions, like the baptisms that make far more sense in this version, there are other details that I must admit are better in the manga. The reason for Claire wanting the save point is a prime example of this. While war is certainly never a good thing, and her concern over Lui is obvious, her decision makes far more sense when Vik is also on the line. Otherwise, a lot of the story is the same, though as always, there are different details available in different versions of the story. We even get a sneak peek into Claire's ideal future and Vik's groups antics before they meet Claire. It is also much clearer that Aunt Anne certainly does have something to do with Charlotte's weakening control over those around them. It would be interesting to see some interaction between Claire and Anne directly, especially if she may have some additional details to the story that Claire has been wondering about.
View all my reviews
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
This covers a few of the volumes in the manga, as expected. While there are some descriptions, like the baptisms that make far more sense in this version, there are other details that I must admit are better in the manga. The reason for Claire wanting the save point is a prime example of this. While war is certainly never a good thing, and her concern over Lui is obvious, her decision makes far more sense when Vik is also on the line. Otherwise, a lot of the story is the same, though as always, there are different details available in different versions of the story. We even get a sneak peek into Claire's ideal future and Vik's groups antics before they meet Claire. It is also much clearer that Aunt Anne certainly does have something to do with Charlotte's weakening control over those around them. It would be interesting to see some interaction between Claire and Anne directly, especially if she may have some additional details to the story that Claire has been wondering about.
View all my reviews
February 4, 2026
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 7
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 7 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Well, this is probably the best they could have hoped for in regards to digging out the Meade family's plots while also finding a way to protect Dion given his current allegiance and the genuine resource he's become for the group. The ball is a little surprising between the unexpected tea party with Nicola and Vik's assertions wanting to provide Claire with a dress the next time and his disappointment in not being able to introduce her to the king yet. Lydia provides a lot of insight there, which is hilarious and also leaves us on a rather large cliff hanger as there's this large hint of things working out but a new obstacle in the way while Claire flails over if she's reading things correctly or not. This is a bit disappointing as there's no news on when the next volume will be released, but still highly enjoyable in this volume. There's a significant difference in things as the group establishes their new friendship, and even Vik seems a little put out when Claire initially clings to formality and protocol with him. I may end up picking up the light novel for this series as I really want to see how things unfold, though unsure if that version of the series is complete or not at this stage. Given the amount of content novels typical cover in comparison to their manga counterparts, it seems certain at least the story would proceed further even though there's currently five volumes of the novel compared to the seven for the manga. Seeing all of the emotions and the artwork is just too good though - need another volume soon!
View all my reviews
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Well, this is probably the best they could have hoped for in regards to digging out the Meade family's plots while also finding a way to protect Dion given his current allegiance and the genuine resource he's become for the group. The ball is a little surprising between the unexpected tea party with Nicola and Vik's assertions wanting to provide Claire with a dress the next time and his disappointment in not being able to introduce her to the king yet. Lydia provides a lot of insight there, which is hilarious and also leaves us on a rather large cliff hanger as there's this large hint of things working out but a new obstacle in the way while Claire flails over if she's reading things correctly or not. This is a bit disappointing as there's no news on when the next volume will be released, but still highly enjoyable in this volume. There's a significant difference in things as the group establishes their new friendship, and even Vik seems a little put out when Claire initially clings to formality and protocol with him. I may end up picking up the light novel for this series as I really want to see how things unfold, though unsure if that version of the series is complete or not at this stage. Given the amount of content novels typical cover in comparison to their manga counterparts, it seems certain at least the story would proceed further even though there's currently five volumes of the novel compared to the seven for the manga. Seeing all of the emotions and the artwork is just too good though - need another volume soon!
View all my reviews
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 6
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 6 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Oddly, Dion genuinely seems perfectly content with his new situation and outlook on life, which in turn has made him a good resource for information for Claire and Vik and the others. With at least some of their past story now public, it's reassuring to see at least this core group believes them, and even some understanding from Vik as he puts the pieces together. There seems to be some hope for the pair there as well given his musings and comments about similarities to his feelings now, not that Claire seems to catch all of them or understand what he means. It's somewhat clearer towards the end of the volume as Claire is abducted by Dion's sister and Vik has to decide if he'll follow her lead and wait or charge in to rescue her right away - though it's clear what his preference would be, just as he struggled in the original storyline with letting Claire find her wings on her own and wanting to keep her by his side. Fortunately, the two goals aligned before, and most likely will again if the two can get back on the same page. Vik is slowly opening up more often, which makes for interesting comparisons from Claire as she reminds herself that they don't have the same relationship now and wonders what is or isn't acceptable, but Vik keeps reaching out in small ways that are encouraging to readers.
View all my reviews
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Oddly, Dion genuinely seems perfectly content with his new situation and outlook on life, which in turn has made him a good resource for information for Claire and Vik and the others. With at least some of their past story now public, it's reassuring to see at least this core group believes them, and even some understanding from Vik as he puts the pieces together. There seems to be some hope for the pair there as well given his musings and comments about similarities to his feelings now, not that Claire seems to catch all of them or understand what he means. It's somewhat clearer towards the end of the volume as Claire is abducted by Dion's sister and Vik has to decide if he'll follow her lead and wait or charge in to rescue her right away - though it's clear what his preference would be, just as he struggled in the original storyline with letting Claire find her wings on her own and wanting to keep her by his side. Fortunately, the two goals aligned before, and most likely will again if the two can get back on the same page. Vik is slowly opening up more often, which makes for interesting comparisons from Claire as she reminds herself that they don't have the same relationship now and wonders what is or isn't acceptable, but Vik keeps reaching out in small ways that are encouraging to readers.
View all my reviews
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 5
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 5 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Well, Dion's arrival certainly explains a lot of the changes at least as far as events in Paffuto and the risk to Claire being able to unleash her full potential. We also meet Vik's older brother, who was not a known part of the original story at all as far as we've seen so far. Understandably, the groups interactions are very different this time around, but there are small snippets here and there that bridge some of the gap and may provide some relief with the changing events. It's clear Claire is learning to understand more of her own feelings, though she remains determined to be content with saving those dear to her. The ending of this volume adds a rather unexpected twist in Claire's encounter with Dion and how that plays out.
View all my reviews
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Well, Dion's arrival certainly explains a lot of the changes at least as far as events in Paffuto and the risk to Claire being able to unleash her full potential. We also meet Vik's older brother, who was not a known part of the original story at all as far as we've seen so far. Understandably, the groups interactions are very different this time around, but there are small snippets here and there that bridge some of the gap and may provide some relief with the changing events. It's clear Claire is learning to understand more of her own feelings, though she remains determined to be content with saving those dear to her. The ending of this volume adds a rather unexpected twist in Claire's encounter with Dion and how that plays out.
View all my reviews
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 4
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 4 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Claire is surprising more than a few people, but who could have suspected events unfolding the way they are. It is yet to be seen how events will unfold entirely, but Claire's suspicion about the game save point at least appears to have been accurate. The cover makes sense with this move back to the past of the game. Fortunately, Claire retains her memories of events in her prior life, allowing her to make decisions based on current events. Things have changed drastically from how they happened in the past however, including the high regard from her family and ex-fiance, and the much earlier events unfolding in Paffuto. Hopefully there won't be too much trouble with her "trespassing" and this very early meeting, though this may be a better scene in private than meeting in a formal setting where they can't really talk at all.
View all my reviews
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Claire is surprising more than a few people, but who could have suspected events unfolding the way they are. It is yet to be seen how events will unfold entirely, but Claire's suspicion about the game save point at least appears to have been accurate. The cover makes sense with this move back to the past of the game. Fortunately, Claire retains her memories of events in her prior life, allowing her to make decisions based on current events. Things have changed drastically from how they happened in the past however, including the high regard from her family and ex-fiance, and the much earlier events unfolding in Paffuto. Hopefully there won't be too much trouble with her "trespassing" and this very early meeting, though this may be a better scene in private than meeting in a formal setting where they can't really talk at all.
View all my reviews
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 3
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 3 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Things progress rather quickly thanks to events at the ball. Some answers forming as well with the introduction of the Meade family, though fortunately Dion does not appear to be as threatening as everyone feared thanks to Claire's new power levels. It seems everyone is seeing Charlotte's true colors, which has her more than a little upset as she is of the opinion everyone should adore her and give her what she wants. The return to Noston is a bit of a surprise, though it also makes sense with the timing of events. Vik has very little patience for those he sees as disregarding Claire and responsible for the perceived pain she must have gone through prior to their meeting. It seems like Claire has a better remaining reputation in her home country than she thought she did, though at least it seems as if those who have run into her so far are respectful of her position with the delegation while clearly curious as to what it means - at least until close to the end.
View all my reviews
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Things progress rather quickly thanks to events at the ball. Some answers forming as well with the introduction of the Meade family, though fortunately Dion does not appear to be as threatening as everyone feared thanks to Claire's new power levels. It seems everyone is seeing Charlotte's true colors, which has her more than a little upset as she is of the opinion everyone should adore her and give her what she wants. The return to Noston is a bit of a surprise, though it also makes sense with the timing of events. Vik has very little patience for those he sees as disregarding Claire and responsible for the perceived pain she must have gone through prior to their meeting. It seems like Claire has a better remaining reputation in her home country than she thought she did, though at least it seems as if those who have run into her so far are respectful of her position with the delegation while clearly curious as to what it means - at least until close to the end.
View all my reviews
February 3, 2026
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 2
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 2 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
There's more than a little bit of misconception going around, but it's adorable and hilarious at the same time. Claire has unintentionally garnered the respect and approval Vik needed to choose her through her actions, though that wasn't her intention. She genuinely just wanted to help everyone. It's rather adorable how Vik's advisors and Miss Isabella are rooting for the pair, though they both seem convinced they should settle for friends and being able to support the other in their goals.
View all my reviews
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
There's more than a little bit of misconception going around, but it's adorable and hilarious at the same time. Claire has unintentionally garnered the respect and approval Vik needed to choose her through her actions, though that wasn't her intention. She genuinely just wanted to help everyone. It's rather adorable how Vik's advisors and Miss Isabella are rooting for the pair, though they both seem convinced they should settle for friends and being able to support the other in their goals.
View all my reviews
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 1
Formerly, the Fallen Daughter of the Duke 1 by Ichibu Saki
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
This follows a lot of similar tropes with the younger step sibling joining the family later on and wanting everything the rich family has, so she paints the older sibling as the villain who looked down on her and made her life miserable, earning the sympathy of those around her, including her older sister's fiance. When the crown prince plans to break their engagement, Claire doesn't truly mind as she adores her younger sister Charlotte, and thinks she would be a better match for the crown prince given their magic rankings after initiation. Except it appears that Claire's ranking was incorrect at first because she didn't have the correct location for her mother's hometown.
Thanks to the isekai aspect of this series, Claire dreams of life as a college student where her closest friend and roommate is playing the very game that she's living - so which one is the real her? The college interactions do glean some information she was otherwise missing however, such as her mother's hometown, and shedding light on why everything changed so drastically among her family and peers.
Claire doesn't let this get her down though, and immediately sets out on her own. The last thing she would have expected would be meeting a female knight (apparently she's the first to realize so quickly according to the other knights) and the crown prince of a neighboring country (though this revelation comes much later). Vik does seem like a genuinely nice guy, though it's also clear he has some sort of interest in Claire even before her re-initiation. Claire seems perfectly content with her new role as a governess and the chance to go back to school and learn about her new abilities. Granted, we haven't met her charge yet, and it would seem there's at least one girl at school that has her sights set on Vik. That could spell some trouble given Vik's clear fondness for Claire and his determination to look out for her.
View all my reviews
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)